If you consistently fail to clock in eight hours of quality shut-eye or have a bed frame with an unusual shape or special dimensions, then it may be time to invest in a custom organic mattress. To take the hassle out of the equation, we put together a list of custom-made non-toxic mattress options below.

Best Custom Organic Mattress Options in 2023

Between writing honest organic mattress reviews, curating roundups of the non-toxic kids mattress brands, spotting the most affordable natural beds, and even tapping into organic RV mattress territory, let’s just say we’ve researched just about every mattress brand on the market. Slumber-worthy mattresses are a true investment and we want to give you the best options possible.

Ideally, most people will want to have full control over the firmness and materials they sleep on every night. It’s been proven that a good night’s sleep can not only improve mood and reduce stress levels, but can also boost immune health and contribute to overall longevity.

Custom organic mattresses can make all the difference in how your body feels when you wake up. They are designed to provide adequate support to your back, neck, spine, hips, and legs. In other words, they are specially designed and created to your (and your partner’s!) specific requirements, preferences, and needs.

However, the entire process of finding and ordering a custom non-toxic mattress can be a bit overwhelming. So here’s a breakdown of the different options that are available on the eco market.

This article contains affiliate links, which means we may earn a commission if you decide to make a purchase.

Featured Image Credit: Savvy Rest

Getting a non-toxic mattress becomes more important when you consider the sheer amount of time spent sleeping over the course of one’s life. If you want to take a deep dive into the problems with conventional mattresses, you can do so in our main mattress guide. But the short version is that typical mattresses can contain things like formaldehyde, flame retardants, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which can contribute to poor air quality in your bedroom.

Non-toxic mattresses are made with materials that are free from those harmful chemicals, which reduces the amount of potentially harmful substances released into the air while you sleep. On top of that, some individuals may be sensitive or allergic to certain chemicals or substances commonly found in mattresses, such as latex or wool. A customized organic mattress made with hypoallergenic materials may help reduce allergy symptoms.

Last but not least, natural mattresses are made with sustainable and eco-friendly materials that are sourced and manufactured in ways that prioritize environmental and social responsibility. So by choosing a mattress from one of the recommended brands below, you actively support businesses that thrive on protecting our planet and workers’ rights.

Do You Really Need a Custom-Made Non-Toxic Mattress?

Unlike a standard off-the-shelf mattress, a custom-made non-toxic mattress is typically made-to-order and can be tailored to fit the unique size, shape, and sleep preferences of the user. They can be designed with specialized features like adjustable firmness levels, targeted support for specific areas of the body, cooling technology to help regulate temperature during sleep, and more.

Of course, anyone can get a custom mattress if you just want to sleep on something that’s more personalized. But here are some extra reasons why you might want a custom-made mattress:

  • If you have an odd-sized bed (like an antique or narrow bed frame or an RV bed)
  • If you are a larger than average person and need extra length or support.
  • If you have chronic pain. Custom mattresses can be designed to provide targeted support and alleviate pressure points.
  • If you have difficulty sleeping due to overheating at night, a custom mattress with cooling technology may help regulate your body temperature and improve your sleep.
  • If you’re an athlete who needs to optimize recovery.
  • If you and your partner have different needs and preferences when it comes to firmness.

Custom Organic Mattresses For Non-Toxic Comfort (In All Sizes, Firmness Levels, & More!)

1. Naturepedic (Best Overall for Custom Organic Mattresses)

naturepedic customizable organic mattress

Non-toxic materials: Certified organic cotton, plant-based PLA, optional GOLS-certified latex and/or wool

If you want to have full control over the comfort level of your organic mattress, look no further than Naturepedic’s collection. You can pick from five different comfort level options: organic latex (in soft, medium, or firm) or microcoils (in soft or medium).

Latex, which is a naturally breathable and temperature-neutral alternative to synthetic PU foam, is touted for its pressure-point relieving qualities, making it one of the more supportive and comfortable choices.

Naturepedic’s microcoils, on the other hand, offer full body-contouring comfort, movement isolation, and balanced support for proper postural alignment.

Plus, the queen-size version (or larger) allows you to customize the sides so you and your partner can each choose your perfect comfort level. You can also switch up and swap out the layers over time to figure out the best combination for you!

Of course, all options are MADE SAFE certified, UL/GREENGUARD certified, and ethically made in the USA with safe and healthy materials. 

And use code thefiltery15 for 15% off.

2. Savvy Rest (Best for Odd-Sized Mattresses)

Non-toxic materials: FSC certified Talalay latex, Dunlop latex, organic cotton and wool

Savvy Rest is a raved-about B Corporation that aims to help us kick toxic chemicals out of our bedrooms once and for all with the help of natural furniture and eco-friendly bedding & mattresses.

Their standard collections are already very customizable, as they allow you to pick the firmness level, springs, and type of latex, but they also offer completely custom-made organic mattresses.

Whether you have an odd-shaped bed or an antique bed frame, have a large body, or are looking for a mattress for your boat, truck, or RV, they’ve got you covered. Savvy Rest’s mattress can be customized to pretty much any length and width you need. They are basically the mecca of custom organic mattresses for ANY and EVERY space and body!

And use the code THEFILTERY20 for 20% off.

3. Obasan (Best Custom Non-Toxic Mattress for Couples)

Best Organic Non-Toxic Mattress for Couples from Obasan

Non-toxic materials: GOTS and GOLS certified organic cotton, rubber, and wool

This Canada-based brand handcrafts custom non-toxic mattresses based on your sleep position, body weight, and body type to ensure perfect support… and they’ve been doing so since 1985! Actually, It takes 15 people to craft an Obasan mattress from start to finish, using the best materials in the world. (And they have all the certifications to prove it.)

It’s easy to customize your mattress using a short quiz. You’ll start by choosing your desired mattress size, then pick the number of sleepers (one or two). Then you’ll provide the height and weight of each sleeper and fill in the information about each person’s body type and favorite sleeping position. Lastly, you will pick the foundation for your custom organic mattress.

The quiz makes it super easy to order, but you can always schedule a free consultation with one of their team members if you need more help.

4. Essentia (Best Custom Organic Memory Foam Mattress)

essentia custom organic mattress

Non-toxic materials: Hevea milk, GOLS certified organic latex, organic essential oils and other plant extracts, GOTS certified organic cotton

Considering a premium custom-made organic mattress to help optimize deep sleep, REM sleep, and overall recovery? Check out the Essentia ProCor P1 Custom Mattress for Athletic Recovery.

Equipped with the brand’s patented technology, the ProCor P1 features all of the 7 key elements for rejuvenating sleep (which includes things like active cooling and optimized oxygen flow), but it’s built specifically for your body.

Essentia’s Beyond Latex™ slow-release organic foam is one of the very few organic foams in the market that can actually compete with conventional memory foam in terms of texture and feel. It helps ensure that each layer will vary to meet the specific posture, muscular, and body needs of the sleeper.

It’s got extra “performance” features, too. For example, the foam is infused with minerals which allows you to sleep up to nine degrees cooler than you would otherwise! They also include a special EMF protection, which optimizes your body’s oxygen flow.

What’s more, it’s manufactured in Essentia’s GOLS and GOTS-certified organic factory in Canada, and every non-toxic mattress is backed by a 20-year limited warranty. 


custom organic mattress from samina sleep

Non-toxic materials: GOLS-certified organic talalay latex, organic cotton or Bio-ceramic® organic cotton, 100% virgin sheep’s wool

SAMINA is so set on making sure you get what the mattress YOU need that you can’t even order one without a consultation with one of their experts!

SAMINA is actually more than just an organic mattress… it’s a completely customized sleep system. It comes with a truly unique mattress that has orthopedic, grounding, and climate-regulating properties. In addition to the standard layers, they can also add extra sections and accessories such as hip boosters (for curvier people) or shoulder boosters (for side sleepers or folks with broad shoulders).

You can also add an adjustable, inclined bed frame, which is great for people with GERD (acid reflux), sleep apnea, and snoring.

The materials come with a handful of non-toxic and organic certifications such as GOTS and GOLS and the frame is finished with organic oils. No metal, flame retardants, or other VOCs are used anywhere.

And use the code THEFILTERY for 5% off your first order.

6. Earthshake

earthsake customizable organic mattress

Non-toxic materials: GOTS organic cotton, wool, GOLS-certified latex

The Utopia is a unique and innovative organic custom mattress that offers a high level of customization, allowing you to adjust the firmness and support levels to meet your individual needs. It’s easy to order; you just toggle the dropdown options to set your preferences. You don’t need to talk to anyone in order to order your mattress.

It’s made up of six interchangeable layers of natural latex, wool batting, and GOTS organic cotton fabric, which can be arranged in different combinations to achieve different levels of firmness and support (soft, medium, or firm).

Plus, the latex used in the mattress is 100% natural and certified by the Global Organic Latex Standard (GOLS), which means it meets strict environmental and social standards. 

As for the wool, it is sourced from small farms in California and Oregon and is certified by the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS). No pesticides or petrochemicals—just pure, tailored-to-you comfort.

We hope this guide has helped you find and order a healthy, custom, organic mattress that is perfect for you! To get new guides delivered to your inbox each week (and lots more exclusive content!), sign up for Filtered Fridays.

About Konstantina

Konstantina Antoniadou is a sustainability writer with an ongoing curiosity to explore new innovative technologies and report on trends in β€œgreen” industries. With almost ten years of expertise in media and publishing and undying love for upbeat and energetic storytelling, Konstantina is at the forefront of the creatively charged fashion, beauty, and non-toxic home verticals. When she’s not crafting ethical shopping guides, she’s either trying to perfect her roller skate dance moves, thrifting, or binging series for the hundredth time.

Related Posts

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *