Whether you’re out running errands, sending your kid back to school, or just trying to be extra careful about not getting sick, sometimes hand sanitizer is necessary.

But not all hand sanitizers are created equal. Not only do many of the popular brands use harsh pesticides as their active ingredient, but you also have to watch out for additives like phthalates and irritating preservatives.

This article will tell you exactly what you need to know about safe hand sanitizer options and some of the best organic and natural hand sanitizer brands.

This article contains affiliate links, which means we may earn commission if you choose to make a purchase.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks for Non-Toxic Hand Sanitizer in 2024

Best Overall Organic Hand Sanitizer (Spray): Primally Pure

Cheapest Non-Toxic Hand Sanitizer: Public Goods

Best Non-Toxic Hand Sanitizer Available in Stores: Honest

Best Alcohol-Free Non-Toxic Hand Sanitizer: Force of Nature (discount code below)

Best Non-Toxic Hand Sanitizer for Kids: ATTITUDE

Best Hand Sanitizing Wipes: EO

Best Moisturizing Hand Sanitizer: Paume

+ more recommendations below!

Cleaning vs. Disinfecting

There are a few different terms to keep in mind when we talk about hand sanitizers, disinfectants, hand soaps, and general all-purpose cleaners. The first thing is the difference between cleaning and disinfecting. They’re not the same thing!

This is how the CDC defines the difference:

  • Cleaning doesn’t necessarily kill germs; rather, it lowers the risk of infection by removing them from the surface and washing them away.
  • Disinfecting actually kills germs, viruses, and bacteria. Disinfecting doesn’t necessarily clean away germs or dirt, but it lowers the risk of illness by killing them off.

So you can clean, you can disinfect, or you can do both. When you put hand sanitizer on your hands, you’re killing germs without actually cleaning them. When you wash your hands, you’re washing the germs away.

Other Cleaning Terms to Know

There are some other similar terms that are worth being familiar with so that you know what you’re buying. The two main things that differentiate these terms are a) where they are used (on living or non-living surfaces) and b) what they kill.

Disinfectant: Kills microorganisms like bacteria and viruses on non-living surfaces (like countertops). Products labeled for disinfection are not meant to be used on skin. They’re not meant to be ingested or inhaled.

Antiseptic: Kills microorganisms like bacteria and viruses on living surfaces (like your skin). Hand sanitizers and hand soaps are classified as antiseptics.

Antibacterial: Antibacterial products are specifically aimed at killing bacteria. You’ll often see the label “antibacterial” on hand soaps. Antibacterial soaps fall under the umbrella of antiseptic products. There is no evidence that antibacterial soaps are any better than plain soap (and that they may even do more damage in the long run), but we’ll get to that in a minute.

Antimicrobial: Whereas antibacterial products kill bacteria, antimicrobials can kill a wider array of microbes, including things like mold, mildew, fungi, viruses, and bacteria.

Sanitizer: To sanitize actually just means to “lower the number of germs on a surface to a safe level.” This can either be through cleaning or disinfecting.

The term “sanitizer” gets confusing, though, because it actually means different things depending on whether it’s being used on a living or non-living surface. “Sanitizers” used on non-living surfaces are regulated as pesticides by the EPA, whereas “hand sanitizers” are regulated by the FDA.

Obviously, for the sake of this article, we’ll be referring to the type of sanitizer that can be used on skin and is regulated by the FDA.

By the way, speaking of cleaning and disinfecting: if you’re also looking for non-toxic all-purpose cleaners for the surfaces in your home, check out this article.

Soap vs. Hand Sanitizer

When cleaning your hands, the CDC recommends that washing your hands with soap and water (for at least 20 seconds) should always be your first choice. It’s the most effective option, not only for getting rid of things like germs, bacteria, and viruses, but also other potential toxins like heavy metals and pesticides (for which hand sanitizer can do basically nothing).

Additionally, hand sanitizers may not be as effective when hands are greasy or dirty, which is another reason to wash them instead.

Hand sanitizer should only be used when soap and water are not available.

Are We Overusing Disinfectants?

You may have heard that our overuse of disinfectants (as well as antibiotics and pesticides) are creating “superbugs” which have evolved to resist those disinfectants and antibiotics. This has the potential to cause serious long-term harm if it means we lose our ability to get rid of these pathogens.

Disinfectants and antibiotics have saved countless lives, but they should probably not be used so liberally. Here are some easy tips to consider:

  • Using regular soap (not the antibacterial kind) and water is your first choice; hand sanitizer is your second.
  • Use discretion when using disinfectants. For example, you may choose to disinfect surfaces when someone in your home is sick, and then stop using them when everyone is healthy again.
  • If and when you do use disinfectants, use the safer kinds. (We’ll get to this next.)
  • Consider the other ingredients in your cleaning products as well, such as fragrances and preservatives. (We’ll get to this in a minute as well.)
  • Always follow the directions on the label.

In short: you don’t necessarily have to totally discontinue using disinfectants and sanitizers—there is certainly an appropriate time and place for them. But decreasing our reliance on them and using them less frequently will likely be better in the long run.

best non toxic hand sanitizer brands

The Best & Worst of Sanitizers/Disinfectants

The next thing to be aware of is the fact that not all disinfection chemicals are the same. Here are the safer and not-so-safe active ingredients to be aware of when picking out your hand sanitizer:

The Safest Sanitizers:

1. Alcohol

Perhaps the most well-known and widely used disinfectant, you’ll find alcohol used in many different hand sanitizer brands. It will kill most bacteria and viruses. It may be listed as ethanol, ethyl alcohol, isopropyl alcohol, or isopropanol.

(Methanol and 1-propanol—two other types of alcohol—are not permitted in these products because of their toxicity. In fact, the FDA has a running list of hand sanitizers that have been found to be contaminated with these types of alcohol, along with other toxins like benzene.)

You’ll want to look for sanitizers that include anywhere from 60-95% alcohol, and you need to use enough that it stays wet on your hands for about 30 seconds.

2. Hypochlorous Acid

Hypochlorous acid (HOCl) is a very safe disinfectant that’s been used in hospitals and medical settings for a long time. It’s actually the disinfection ingredient used in Force of Nature all-purpose cleaner, which you can read more about here. In fact, Force of Nature sells mini spray bottles that you can throw in your purse or diaper bag and use as a sanitizer on-the-go.

The biggest downside to using hypochlorous acid is that it loses its effectiveness rather quickly. Your Force of Nature cleaner will need to be replaced every two weeks. So this isn’t really the best option unless you’re going through a lot of it. (Or you could just not fill up your travel spray bottle all the way.)

3. Hydrogen Peroxide

Hydrogen peroxide is another effective disinfectant that will kill most things, but you have to be more careful with it. It should never be mixed with bleach or vinegar, and you should keep it away from heat and sunlight. You should also only use it in small amounts (like 3% concentration for hand sanitizer).

4. Certain Essential Oils

Certain plant-based essential oils have natural antibacterial properties. Thymol is probably the most common one, and there are a number of cleaning products using thymol that have been approved by the EPA.

Citric acid is another plant-based oil that’s approved by the EPA as a disinfectant.

Keep in mind that even though these are natural ingredients, they can still irritate the nose, eyes, and lungs of some people (and especially at high concentrations).

Additionally, just because something contains essential oils as the active ingredient doesn’t automatically mean that all of the other ingredients in the product are perfectly safe. Beware of greenwashing.

What about vinegar?

Vinegar is a favorite household cleaning product used by many people. Even though it’s great at cleaning and may have some ability to kill certain types of germs, it’s not as effective as the other active ingredients listed here. It’s not recommended for hand sanitizer.

Sanitizers to Avoid:

1. Quats

Quaternary ammonium chlorides, a.k.a. quats, are extremely common in disinfecting and sanitizing products. They are registered with the EPA as pesticides and they come with many potential problems, including lung and skin irritation (like dermatitis and asthma) as well as reproductive harm and infertility.

Quats are a class of chemicals, so they can look like many different things on an ingredient label. They usually have “…onium chloride” in the name. For example, benzalkonium chloride (the active ingredient in Wet Ones wipes).

2. Sodium Hypochlorite (Chlorine/Bleach)

You won’t find this ingredient in hand sanitizers, but you will find it in other home disinfection products, so it’s worth being aware of. Chlorine is a known toxin to humans and wildlife that can irritate the skin and respiratory tract, and create various carcinogenic byproducts.

Other Hand Sanitizer Ingredients to Avoid

Besides the active ingredient, there are other potentially problematic ingredients that are commonly found in hand sanitizers. These ingredients are also common in other cleaning and personal care products. This isn’t an exhaustive list, but these are some of the harsh chemicals you’ll most likely find in conventional hand sanitizers:

1. Undisclosed Fragrance

Just like so many other consumer products, hand sanitizers come with the word “fragrance” or “parfum” on their ingredient label. Because of a loophole in disclosure regulations, manufacturers can legally “hide” almost 4,000 different ingredients under the word “fragrance” without actually telling consumers what those ingredients are.

While some are perfectly safe, other ingredients include phthalates, other endocrine disruptors, allergens, and more.

It can be difficult to avoid “fragrance,” especially when shopping in stores. However, when you can, try to avoid products with “fragrance” listed in the ingredient list and/or make sure the company provides their full ingredients online.

You can read more about this issue here.

2. Certain Preservatives

Preservatives like methylisothiazolinone are commonly used in personal care products—even some of the ones labeled as “natural.” Many of these preservatives are irritants, and some (like parabens) are even endocrine disruptors. They’re not necessary for hand sanitizers.

3. Dyes

Most dyes are synthetics that are derived from petroleum. There is certainly a spectrum in terms of how potentially toxic a colorant is (and how much safety information we even have), so it depends on the kind and color being used.

But when it comes to hand sanitizer, they’re just unnecessary. No one needs their hand sanitizer to be blue or green; it’s just one more ingredient to wonder and worry about. You can just skip the colored sanitizers.

4. Triclosan

This ingredient used to be very common in disinfection products but has since been mostly banned. But if you have any old sanitizers with this ingredient or find any bottles overseas containing it, steer clear.

What About the Wipes?

Wipes are difficult because you have to wonder about what the fabric is made of too. Many conventional cleaning wipes are made using synthetic materials, which will break down into microplastics and end up in our ecosystems and food supplies.

A ‘better’ alternative involves using rayon fabric wipes, which is what EO uses. But this really isn’t a perfect solution either because the process of making rayon is (usually) toxic to workers and surrounding communities. We haven’t found a good sanitizing wipe made from a truly all-natural material, but we’ll be sure to update you if and when we do.

Safer Hand Sanitizer Ingredients to Look for Instead

Generally, hand sanitizer ingredient lists don’t need to be very long. You basically need:

  • an antiseptic ingredient (like alcohol),
  • some sort of conditioning agent to help prevent the alcohol from totally drying out your hands,
  • and a few scents to balance out the strong alcohol smell.

Instead of things like propylene glycol, many of the brands below use moisturizing agents like glycerin, aloe vera, or hyaluronic acid. (P.S. You can also check out this article with our favorite non-toxic lotion brands to help keep your hands from drying out!)

In general, essential oils are better for fragrance (just be aware that certain ones, such as lemon and lime, are allergens for some people).

For gels, there’s usually a thickener added. Aloe is a great thickener because it doubles as a moisturizer. Guar and xanthan gum are good ones, too.

Can Hand Sanitizer Be Certified Organic?

Yes. You’ll notice that some of the products listed here are certified organic and others aren’t. Some brands use some organically-grown ingredients, but not enough to warrant an organic label for the entire product. Sometimes companies choose not to obtain a certification from a third-party label because of how costly it can be for a small business.

Just remember that just because something has an organic label doesn’t automatically mean it’s non-toxic, and just because something is not organic doesn’t mean it’s automatically unsafe or unhealthy.

Hand Sanitizer & BPA (Be Careful With Receipts!)

There’s one more thing to bear in mind when it comes to hand sanitizer use, and that’s the fact that using hand sanitizer can increase skin absorption of toxic BPA and other bisphenols.

Many people grab a pump of hand sanitizer at the grocery store, which is understandable considering grocery carts are kinda disgusting. But then they grab their receipt, which is most likely covered in high concentrations of BPA, BPS, or BPF (unless they’re shopping at one of the few stores that have removed bisphenols from their receipts, like Costco, Target, or CVS!).

(Bisphenols are used on thermal paper like receipts, labels, and tickets as a part of the heat-activated printing process.)

Handling receipts right after applying hand sanitizer has actually been found to significantly increase BPA absorption compared to handling receipts normally (without the hand sani).

So basically: if and when you do use hand sanitizer, get rid of your receipt first!

This also leaves a question about the bottles hand sanitizers come in… Do they contain bisphenols? Well, that’s one of the reasons why Primally Pure is our top pick: it comes in a glass bottle, which is naturally bisphenol-free.

As for the other brands, we’ve reached out to companies to ask whether their bottles are free from all bisphenols and we’ve notated which ones answered us. In the meantime, this is another reason for not over-using hand sanitizer and just using it when you really need to.

Our Favorite Non-Toxic & Organic Hand Sanitizer Brands

Alright, now let’s get to it! Here are our favorite non-toxic and organic hand sanitizer brands that are using safe, clean, and effective ingredients:

1. Primally Pure (Best Overall for Organic Hand Sanitizer)

organic hand sanitizer from primally pure

Active Ingredient: Alcohol
Organic? Yes
Type: Spray
Price: $10-12

Primally Pure carries two different versions of hand sanitizer.

The “Immune Boosting” version, which has a stronger smell and comes with several different types of antimicrobial essential oils (including thyme, eucalyptus, and tea tree). Their regular version has a much lighter smell and comes with fewer (and less intense) essential oils like lavender, peppermint, and rosemary.

In addition to the grape alcohol, which doubles as both a sanitizer as well as a natural preservative, these formulations also contain aloe vera and glycerin, which help to prevent your hands from becoming all dried out.

Although it doesn’t come with a third-party certification, all of the ingredients used are organic. They’re either wildcrafted or sourced from small family farms and then hand-formulated in California.

Plus, these hand sanitizers come in a glass jar to decrease plastic use and potential BPA exposure.

2. Public Goods (Cheapest Non-Toxic Hand Sanitizer)

Active Ingredient: Alcohol
Organic? No
Type: Spray, gel, and wipes
Price: $3

If you’re on a tight budget, Public Goods might be the best place to stock up on hand sanitizer. They offer a hand sanitizer gel, which comes in a 2 oz bottle ($2.95) or 12 oz bottle ($7.95). They also offer a 2 oz hand sanitizing spray ($4.95) and a kit that includes a travel-sized spray, gel, and pack of N-95 masks.

In addition to the alcohol, their sanitizers come with gentle essential oils like lavender oil, cucumber, chamomile flower, and white tea. Some of their ingredients are organic and some aren’t.

3. Honest (Best Non-Toxic Hand Sanitizer That’s Available in Stores)

Active Ingredient: Alcohol
Organic? No
Type: Spray, gel, and wipes
Price: $3+

If you’re looking to pick up some hand sanitizer at the store, Honest is likely going to be your best bet. It’s available at places like Target, Walmart, Meijer, and more.

They have a lot of different kinds to choose from, too: sprays, gels, and wipes that come in a variety of sizes and scents. The wipes can be used both on hands as well as hard surfaces.

In addition to the active ingredient of alcohol, they also include glycerin, aloe vera, and various natural oils. We recommend the fragrance free/free & clear versions first, followed by the lavender ones, and then the others.

To take a deeper dive into the Honest brand as a whole, click here.

Shop Honest’s hand sanitizer online or at Target.

4. ATTITUDE (Best Non-Toxic Hand Sanitizer for KIDS)

Active Ingredient: Ethyl alcohol
Organic? No
Type: Spray
Price: $6

If you really love scented products, you will love ATTITUDE. In terms of hand sanitizer, they have several different scents to choose from, including a kids collection.

Their ingredient lists are pretty short and come with various essential oils, depending on which scent you choose. Standard scents include Lemon, Orange, and Olive. Their “Little Leaves” collection is formulated using scents that tend to be less bothersome for little ones, including Vanilla & Pear, Mango, Watermelon & Coco.

I’ve been using the Vanilla & Pear one and I really like the smell – it’s nice and sweet, but not too overpowering!

ATTITUDE’s products are made in Canada and come with several different third-party certifications, including EWG Verified (for ingredient safety), ECOLOGO (for environmental sustainability), and PETA (vegan & cruelty-free).

ATTITUDE has also told us that their bottles are free from BPA and other bisphenols.

5. Force of Nature (Best Alcohol-Free Non-Toxic Hand Sanitizer)

non toxic alcohol free hand sanitizer from force of nature

Active Ingredient: Hypochlorous acid
Organic? No
Type: Spray
Price: $80 (solution starter kit), $12 (3-pack of travel-sized bottles)

There aren’t very many options for truly non-toxic alcohol-free hand sanitizers, but Force of Nature is a great choice. It uses only two ingredients—hypochlorous acid and sodium hydroxide—and combines them with water and electricity to create a powerful disinfectant and cleaner.

(This kind of cleaner has been used in medical settings for a long time and Force of Nature is the first company to find a way to bring it to people’s homes.)

The only significant downside to Force of Nature is that you have to replenish it after two weeks. So if you do use it as a hand sanitizer, you may want to just fill up your travel bottle halfway so it doesn’t have to go to waste.

Read our full review of Force of Nature here or use the code THEFILTERY30 for 30% off your own Starter Kit or bundle.

6. Paume (Best Moisturizing Non-Toxic Hand Sanitizer)

non toxic hand sanitizer from paume

Active Ingredient: Alcohol
Organic? Contains some organic ingredients
Type: Gel
Price: $28+

Paume is a newer hand care brand with a great aesthetic. It’s a great option for the home because they have a larger pump dispenser that looks nice on the countertop, on the diaper changing table, or in the bathroom. (Plus you can use it one-handed, which makes it great for parents.)

They also have a travel-sized bottle, a refill pouch, and a few other hand care products like a balm and hand soap.

In addition to the alcohol, they use other natural and healthy ingredients like witch hazel, moisturizing aloe vera, and organic essential oils. Although it’s not a plastic-free brand, they do offset their plastic to make everything plastic-neutral. It’s also vegan and Leaping Bunny Certified to be cruelty-free.

7. EO / everyone (Best for Non-Toxic Hand Sanitizing Wipes)

Active Ingredient: Alcohol
Organic? Contains some organic ingredients
Type: Spray, Gel, & Spray
Price: $30+ (comes in multi-packs)

EO and everyone are two sister brands that exist under the EO Products umbrella company. Between the two brands, they have a selection of different cleansing and sanitizing wipes, sprays, and gels that come in various scents and sizes.

Ingredients mostly just consist of alcohol, glycerin, and plant-based oils (which vary depending on the scent). Although they don’t come with any third-party organic certifications, many of the ingredients they use are organic.

EO told us that their bottles do not contain any added BPA and that they are made with 100% recycled plastic. (Unfortunately, however, it’s almost impossible to tell whether recycled plastic contains things like bisphenols or phthalates because we don’t know where the original plastic came from or how it was made.)

You can find EO and everyone products on Thrive Market (EO, everyone) or Walmart, or their respective websites (EO, everyone).

8. Dr. Bronner’s

Active Ingredient: Alcohol
Organic? Yes
Type: Spray
Price: $5

Dr. Bronner’s is one of my favorite brands for non-toxic and organic hand sanitizer. It has a very simple ingredient list (Organic Fair Trade Ethyl Alcohol (62%), Water, Organic Glycerin, and either Organic Lavender Oil or Organic Peppermint Oil). All of the ingredients are organic (except the water of course) and the alcohol is also Fair Trade certified.

Dr. Bronner’s has been around since 1985 and is trusted for cleaning and personal care products that are simple, eco-friendly, and effective.

Dr. Bronner’s hand sanitizer is available at online stores like Thrive Market and Hive as well as in big box stores like Walmart.

9. All Good

Active Ingredient: Alcohol
Organic? No
Type: Spray and Gel
Price: $4

All Good’s hand sanitizers come with a relatively short ingredient list, which includes alcohol, glycerin, and a few essential oils (including thyme).

All Good’s company comes with various third-party labels, including B Corp, 1% for the Planet, Leaping Bunny, and Climate Neutral. We’ve also confirmed with All Good that their bottles are free from BPA and other bisphenols.

(Easy!) DIY Non-Toxic Hand Sanitizer Recipes

If you prefer to do things the DIY-way or you’re just in a bind and need to make something out of what you already have at home, here are a few ideas:

  1. In a bind, you can use 60-95% rubbing alcohol by itself. (I don’t recommend this for long-term use, though, because it will probably dry out your skin.)
  2. In a spray bottle, mix 2/3 cup of rubbing alcohol, 1/3 cup of aloe vera, and 10 drops of essential oils of your choice (optional). Shake the closed bottle to mix it all together.
  3. Alternatively, you can use 2/3 cup of rubbing alcohol, 1/3 cup of coconut oil (instead of aloe vera), and 10 drops of essential oils of your choice.

Just-Okay / Not-Great Hand Sanitizer Brands

Here are some more brands we investigated which we can’t fully recommend:

100% Pure: 100% Pure carries a lot of great non-toxic and organic products, but unfortunately, their hand sanitizer contains triethanolamine, which is a known irritant/allergen.

Babyganics: Babyganics’ alcohol-free hand sanitizer contains benzalkonium chloride as its active ingredient, which can cause severe skin, eye, and respiratory irritation and allergies. It’s not suitable for anyone with allergies, sensitive skin, or skin conditions like eczema.

Hello Bello: Their hand sanitizers are okay, but they contain polysorbate 20 (which comes with contamination concerns) as well as undisclosed “natural fragrance.”

Mrs. Meyer’s: Not terrible, but contains several not-great fragrance ingredients.

Puracy: Puracy carries a gel sanitizer that comes in several different sizes. The only concern with this one that it contains “natural fragrance” without actually listing what that is.

Touchland: This is a relatively eco-friendly brand that has nice branding and comes in a nice pocket-friendly bottle shape. However, we only recommend the unscented version because the others contain undisclosed fragrance ingredients.

FAQs About Non-Toxic & Organic Hand Sanitizer

What is organic hand sanitizer?

Organic hand sanitizer may be made with fully or partially organic ingredients. The active ingredient may be organic (like organic alcohol, or example), and/or the inactive ingredients may be organic (such as organic aloe vera or essential oils). You may want to look for third-party organic certifications when possible, like USDA.

Is Purell hand sanitizer toxic?

Unfortunately, Purell’s line of hand sanitizers are filled with problematic ingredients, including quats, fragrances, dyes, and more. Their Purell “Naturals” option, however, is actually pretty good. The only ingredient of potential concern is aminomethyl propanol, which is considered an irritant, is potentially toxic to wildlife, and can come with certain contamination concerns.

Is organic hand sanitizer good?

Yes, as long as there is an effective active ingredient for disinfection (such as alcohol), organic hand sanitizer can be just as good as more ‘conventional’ brands of hand sanitizer.

About Abbie

Abbie Davidson is the Creator & Editor of The Filtery. With almost a decade of experience in sustainability, she researches and writes content with the aim of helping people minimize environmental toxins in an in-depth yet accessible way.

Related Posts

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *